How Herkimer County compares · From the counties’ own budgets, line by line

Public defender: Herkimer County beside counties of similar size in New York

Compare with:My size, my stateMy size, nationwideMy neighborsMy whole stateThe whole nation
Show:Per residentTotal dollars

Herkimer County: $1.3 million, 33rd highest of 35. The middle of the group is $2.7 million; the middle half runs from $1.8 million to $3.5 million (34 counties with figures).

#CountyResidentsAmountPer residentWhere it comes from
1Ontario County, NY113,012$6.7 million$59.14/res.Public Defender $6.7 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
2Wayne County, NY90,757$5.1 million$56.34/res.Public Defender $5.1 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
3Tompkins County, NY105,602$5.1 million$48.24/res.Public Defender $5.1 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
4Oswego County, NY118,305$5.1 million$42.97/res.Public Defender $5.1 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
5Cattaraugus County, NY75,475$4.7 million$62.55/res.Public Defender $4.7 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
6St. Lawrence County, NY106,198$4.5 million$42.54/res.Public Defender $4.5 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
7Steuben County, NY92,015$4.3 million$46.73/res.Public Defender $4.3 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
8Sullivan County, NY80,450$4.2 million$51.91/res.Public Defender $4.2 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
9Madison County, NY67,072$3.5 million$52.26/res.Public Defender $3.5 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
10Washington County, NY59,839$3.5 million$58.27/res.Public Defender $3.5 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
11Putnam County, NY98,409$3.4 million$34.46/res.Public Defender $3.4 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
12Cortland County, NY45,945$3.4 million$73.52/res.Public Defender $3.4 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
13Warren County, NY65,288$3.3 million$49.84/res.Public Defender $3.3 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
14Clinton County, NY77,871$2.9 million$37.13/res.Public Defender $2.9 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
15Cayuga County, NY74,567$2.8 million$38.06/res.Public Defender $2.8 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
16Essex County, NY36,744$2.7 million$74.25/res.Public Defender $2.7 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
17Jefferson County, NY113,140$2.7 million$23.82/res.Public Defender $2.7 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
18Livingston County, NY61,561$2.6 million$42.36/res.Public Defender $2.6 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
19Franklin County, NY47,086$2.5 million$53.13/res.Public Defender $2.5 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
20Montgomery County, NY49,648$2.5 million$50.09/res.Public Defender $2.5 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
21Allegany County, NY47,299$2.3 million$48.04/res.Public Defender $2.3 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
22Greene County, NY46,903$2.2 million$47.89/res.Public Defender $2.2 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
23Fulton County, NY52,073$2.2 million$42.14/res.Public Defender $2.2 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
24Otsego County, NY60,524$2.1 million$35.17/res.Public Defender $2.1 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
25Schoharie County, NY30,151$1.8 million$60.95/res.Public Defender $1.8 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
26Delaware County, NY44,191$1.8 million$40.57/res.Public Defender $1.8 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
27Genesee County, NY57,604$1.7 million$30.22/res.Public Defender $1.7 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
28Tioga County, NY47,574$1.7 million$34.91/res.Public Defender $1.7 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
29Chenango County, NY45,776$1.6 million$35.34/res.Public Defender $1.6 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
30Columbia County, NY60,299$1.6 million$26.42/res.Public Defender $1.6 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
31Chemung County, NY81,115$1.6 million$19.61/res.Public Defender $1.6 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
32Seneca County, NY32,650$1.5 million$44.55/res.Public Defender $1.5 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
33Herkimer County, NY59,585$1.3 million$22.34/res.Public Defender $1.3 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
34Wyoming County, NY39,588$1.2 million$31.06/res.Public Defender $1.2 million · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)
35Orleans County, NY39,686$912,775$23.00/res.Public Defender $912,775 · in General Government · name contains “public defender” (2024, actual spending)

Who’s in the group: Counties in the same state with between half and double its population (2024 Census estimate). If fewer than five fit, the eight closest in population. Source: Each county’s own adopted budget: Arkansas counties from their appropriation ordinances, Idaho counties from their filings with the State Controller, and the other full County Commons sites from their published budgets. Every line is matched to one shared category, by Arkansas’s standard department code where there is one, otherwise by words in its name — open any category to see each line and the rule that matched it, and download every line. Years differ (most are 2026 or fiscal 2025) and so do the jobs counties do, so read these as a guide to scale. Only counties whose budgets we’ve read can appear here; for the rest this is a dead end until their budget is read.